Are You Lending or Selling Your Product?

November 14, 2011

The Return of Used Items
Retailers are well aware that there are consumers who feel it’s just fine to “borrow” items from retailers. Use them and return them.  It might be a formal dress for the important wedding, shoes for a job interview, a large screen tv for the big game, or a ladder for the occasional around the house job.

“Wardrobing” is a Major Problem and Getting Worse
In the retail industry it’s called wardrobing. That’s the return on used, non-defective merchandise.  And 61.4% of retailers have dealt with this problem, says a study released last week by the National Retail Federation. That’s up twenty percent from just two years ago, when the estimate was a still serious 42% of retailers said they had to deal with this.

Buy/Return or Shoplift/Return
We’ve discussed the problem of return fraud in the past. For example, look at our Shoplift/Return Cycle article.  It’s a related problem. But with wardrobing the product is actually purchased, though there’s no intention of keeping it after use.

Shark Tag is an unobtrusive, though obvious, tag used to deter the return of used items, sometimes called "retail rental" or "wardrobing."

Like most retail theft prevention issues, it creates a dichotomy for store owners.  Fast, convenient return policies make for happy customers and often increase sales.  On the other hand, overly lax return policies often results include people returning  merchandise stolen from your store (that means you’re being robbed twice!!) or returning products from other stores, Sometimes consumers get the feeling that it’s ok to return merchandise that they’ve used.

But you can’t sell used or damaged merchandise as new.

What Can Retailers Do?
You can develop restrictive, though reasonable return policies. Whatever you do, you have to make sure it matches your needs, balancing customer service and loss prevention.

A few approaches might be:

  • Require identification, and keep an internal database of returns
  • Use a service that provides a database of return activities across stores and chains
  • Require receipts for cash returns
  • Only issue refunds in the same method of payment as the original purchase
  • Consider a restocking fee for open, non-defective merchandise
  • Train employees to recognize return fraud

Whatever you do, make sure your policy is clear to customers.

The Shark Tag
Alpha Security Product’s new Shark Tag is effective at deterring wardrobers from purchasing, using and returning items for a full refund.

Key features of the Shark Tag are:

Shark Tag can be used to protect hardware items

Shark Tag can be used to protect hardware items

  • Fastens securely with a pin to the front of a garment, providing a strong visual deterrent
  • Pin can secure stores Return Policy if you want (ie, no returns or a restock fee if the tag is removed)
  • Tag is easily removed at home by customer with household scissors
  • Tag cannot be replaced on garment without obvious evidence of tampering
  • The Shark Tag being used to preventing “retail renting” of home improvement items

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!

American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Shoplifter Locks Herself Out

October 7, 2011

Is Everybody Getting Smarter?
Our last post mentioned that both shoplifters and retailers are getting smarter when dealing with theft.

image source: mrkeyman.com

But this report from the Cookeville, Tennessee Herald-Citizen shows that might not be completely true.

A Dollar Store employee claims to have seen a woman place several items into her purse. The employee approached the woman, giving her a chance to pay for the items.

“She walked out of the store, but when she got to her vehicle, she realized that she had locked her keys in the vehicle and she came back in,”

says the police report.

Not all shoplifters are professionals.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!

American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Everybody’s Getting Smarter

October 4, 2011

There’s a very interesting, and well written, article in this past Sunday’s Arizona Republic. Titled “As Criminal Gangs Get Smarter, Retailers Find Tools to Fight Back,” the writer details a range of products being stolen, methods being used by thieves, how retailers and police are reacting.

Despite Effective Theft Prevention, Thieves Continue to Multiply,
says the writer. “The petty shoplifters and price-tag switchers” are still part of the problem. But gangs, inexpensive and new technology and sometimes employees on the inside are increasing challenging retailers. And then, stolen goods are often farmed out to a complex distribution system.

In Your Town As Well
Increased retail theft in Phoenix, highlights the fact that what happens in one city impacts others. Earlier this year, the National Retail Federation added Phoenix and Las Vegas to Organized Retail Top Ten list.

Joseph LaRocca, the National Retail Federation’s senior adviser of asset protection, said that crackdowns of organized retail theft in other metro areas have prompted thieves to move into the Phoenix area.

Shoplifters do react to anti-shoplifting efforts. They move to where the shoplifting is easier.

You Can Do Something about Shoplifting

Spider Wraps in use at Target

"This is called a spider wrap....It's proven very effective deterrent for us," Nate Hartle Target Sr Mgr for Investigations told MN Public Radio. (photo source: MN Public Radio)

The article points out that theft prevention means “walking a fine line.” You have to focus on retail security while still being customer friendly.

The article points to several techniques being implemented.

Target uses electronic “spider wraps,” which wrap around boxes of containing video players, televisions, gaming consoles and other often-stolen items. The wraps prevent boxes from being opened inside the store or taken outside.

The retailer and others also use anti-sweep hooks that prevent thieves from scooping up whole racks of products and bolting. There are locking racks that require an attendant to open and special hangers that prevent thieves from cutting merchandise off a locking rack.

There are certainly many more techniques, including cooperation with your local law enforcement authorities and other retailers.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!

American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Does Shoplifting Happen Only During the Night?

September 9, 2011

Imposing a Curfew for Shoplifting?

In the small town of Nailsea, in southwest UK, a 28-year-old man was convicted of stealing two bottles of aftershave from a local pharmacy / beauty supply store.

In addition to paying compensation of over $1,000 to the store, and $135 for the cost of prosecution, the convicted shoplifter was sentenced to an 7 pm  to 7 am curfew for two months.

Nailsea UK, where an shoplfiter stole aftershave lotion

Nailsea Town Centre. A man was sentanced to a two month curfew for shoplfiting from a pharmacy / health & beauty supply store.

This isn’t the first time this type of punishment was imposed on a repeat shoplifter in the UK.  For example, in Whitehaven, along the Irish Sea, a 23-year-old woman faced a similar sentence for shoplifting food and stealing alcohol from a supermarket.  And in Cornwall, a 33-year-old mother of five received the same curfew. She was convicted of stealing jeans from a local clothing store.

Does the Sentence Make Sense?

Maybe, maybe not. Sentencing in each situation is a different. In all cases, these were repeat shoplifters.

Were the judges concerned about the cost of holding someone in prison?  Were they looking at the personal situation of the convicted retail thieves and the  impact of home curfews as opposed to other penalties? Do they  judges believe shoplfiters steal primarily in the evening?

This isn’t a legal blog, so I’ll leave that to you to think about.

Prime Time for Shoplifters

As retailers, we know very well that shoplifting can occur anytime of the day or night.

That said, there are certain times that stores are more vulnerable.

  • At opening and closing, when staff is busier and distracted
  • During particularly busy times of the shopping day

You Can Do Something About Shoplifting

  1. Have enough staff on hand during opening and closing.  Make sure you have sufficient coverage for both the required opening and closing routines, to help customers and to know what’s going on in your store.
  2. Know your busy times.  People counters help you keep track of the hours you need increased staff.
  3. Train your employees on proper customer service.  Let them know that great service is the number on theft prevention tool and the number one selling tool.
  4. Allow your employees enough time to prepare the store before opening and do the necessary closing routines after customers are gone.
  5. Keep Your Store Neat and Organized.  It keeps your sales staff busy and on the sales floor.  It helps point out missing items quickly.
  6. Use Electronic Article Surveillance systems to help protect your inventory.  No other technology provides a more timely manner of letting you know if someone is walking out of your store with products they haven’t paid for.

Your thoughts? Share them here.

What do you think about the validity of curfews for shoplifters?

Do you know shoplifting’s prime times in your store?

What are you doing to help protect your store during busy times?
————————
You can do something about shoplifting!

American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

NRF Loss Prevention Conference 2011

June 15, 2011

It’s the largest conference in the US dealing with shoplifting and loss prevention. And it’s just ending in Dallas.

The conference deals with the full range of loss prevention issues, not just shoplifting and organized retail crime. It also covers safety, physical security and just about anything else that helps protect retailer assets. On display at the expo was everything from the from the latest technologies to “old school” proven solutions.

It’s one of those shows that are just as valuable for smaller retailers as it is for the largest national firms.

Here’s a link to a report on the show from NBC Dallas Ft Worth.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!
American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Shoplifting Ring Focuses on HBA

June 1, 2011

Florida Ring Busted
Tampa area police have busted a shoplifting ring that seemed to focus on health and beauty items….Products like Crest White Strips, Rogaine hair growth products and diet pills.

 

HBA Are a Major Theft Target
This Tampa area group of three is alleged to have stolen more than $200,000 worth of products in the past six months. And they are not alone.

Looking at theft in the North America, the  2009 Global Retail Theft Barometer identified “Cosmetics/perfume/beauty supply/pharmacy” as the market segment with the highest shrink rate.

Most Vulnerable Merchandise
In a presentation to retailers earlier this year, Professor Joshua Bamfield, principal author of the Retail Theft Barometer and Director of the Centre for Retail Research in the UK pointed out that “the most vulnerable merchandise” varies between retailers.

Generally speaking, however, merchandise becomes particularly vulnerable because of

  • Resale Value
  • Brand Desirability
  • Product Size
  • Total Demand
  • Cult or Fad Interest
  • Drug Relationship

You Can Protect Your Products
A study by the Loss Prevention Research Council, for example, showed a significant cut in shrink when stores used Alpha Keepers to help protect razor blades. A 2001 study, by PriceWaterhouseCoopers, showed shrinkage coming down nearly 70 percent when they studied the use of Checkpoint Electronic Article Surveillance Systems to help protect analgesics, vitamins, batteries, film, cosmetics and spirits.

Over the past several years, manufacturers have developed specialized products to help protect high risk health and beauty products from theft.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!
American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Flash Mob Shoplifting

May 23, 2011

Along Chicago’s Magnificent Mile — where the Black Eyed Peas opened Oprah’s 24th season with the world’s largest Flash Mob dance –  shoplifting is down this year. Arrests for retail theft are down two percent.

Theft from one group, however, has seen a dramatic rise. Juvenile arrests are up ten percent over last year. In Chicago, and throughout the country, “Flash Mob’s” are becoming associated with shoplifting as well.

Social Media
Authorities say that groups of youth have coordinated their shoplifting activity using social media…announcing times and locations of thefts.

In one reported Michigan Avenue incident, thieves yelled “Snatch” to start the raid.

Chicago area police and local business aren’t ready to call this an epidemic, yet. But this type of activity has taken place elsewhere in the US. And police are reacting with their own efforts.

You Can Do Something About Shoplifting
Working with local business, police have stepped up patrols and are monitoring social media.  Retailers are sharing information about thefts in the area. Stores are training their employees to recognize and deal with shoplifters. And they’re using anti-shoplifting products.

Police say these efforts are having a positive impact. There have been fewer cases of flash mobs targeting Mag Mile stores in recent months, Kenneth Angarone, Commander of the local police district told the Chicago Sun-Times “But,” he warned, “smaller groups — of two or three teens at a time — are continuing to shoplift in the area.”

Here’s what Flash Mobs are Meant for

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!
American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft . Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

LP in a Box

April 5, 2011

Loss Prevention experts say that

Theft, errors or fraud can account for more than half a retailer’s overall profit loss.

Can you afford to avoid the issue?
Are you looking to implement a more organized, sustained, loss prevention program, but don’t think you can afford a full-fledged loss prevention consultant?

LP in a Box has been implemented by small retailers and franchises throughout the United States

Successfully implemented at small retailers and franchises throughout the US

LP in a Box ®
LP Innovations, Inc has put together a do-it-yourself program focused on educating employees and implementing procedures to cut loss and improve profitability.

LP In a Box includes material and guidebooks for management and associates focused on both internal and external sources of theft. The program helps managers carry out practices that the can detect possible areas of theft.

Materials Include:

  • Employee Awareness Guide – introductory training
  • Management Best Practices Guide – focused on both theft and error. Includes a roll out strategy and suggested activities
  • Monthly Topic Posters – covering various topics and discussion points
  • Store Audit Checklists – helps you implement “best practices”
  • Stickers and Magnets – promotes ongoing loss prevention awareness
  • Tender Validation Guide – quickly verify suspicious currency, credit cards and more

Specialized Programs
At this point, LP Innovations has developed a program aimed at retailers of all categories and a second program with items and text specific to convenience stores and fuel stations.

For more information
Click on this link or give American Theft Prevention Products a call. We’re dedicated to identifying and delivering the most cost-effective theft prevention solutions to retail, commercial and educational institutions.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting!
American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers and others combat shoplifting and theft . Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Bagel Brained Shoplifter

March 20, 2011

 

Stealing Lox from a Brooklyn Shop

High Theft Products Like Lox stolen

Shoplifting lox at a Brooklyn deli. Image source: www.glattkosherflorida.com

I can’t say it any better than this post from The Gothamist.

In the most pun-packed story we’ve read in the NY Post for quite some time, the tabloid giddily reports that “a bagel-brained bandit stuffed a dozen packs of smoked salmon in his pants at a Brooklyn deli—but got schmeared by a couple of workers before he could get out the door, police said yesterday. And now he’s the catch of the day at Rikers.”

Here’s a link to the original NY Post story.

The creative writer at the Gothamist concludes:

You mess with their lox, you’re gonna get creamed.

Enjoy the day.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting! American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers combat shoplifting. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

$100 Reward for Reporting Shoplifting

March 16, 2011

“What’s to be done about shoplifting?”
asks Canadian syndicated columnist, and economist, Bruce Whitestone.

In a column this week, Whitestone claims “that when it comes to thwarting culprits, stores seem unable to be innovative.”

“Clearly,” he says, “different methods need to be adopted.” He argues for better employee screening, and suggests that it might be effective to impose first offense jail terms and mandatory sentencing for second offenses.

An Economist’s SuggestionAsking the public to report shoplifters

Then, as economists often do, he looks at financial incentives.

Stores should offer customers a $100 reward or anyone seeing and reporting shoplifting.

Shoplifters would not know who’s watching them, writes Whitestone, and “customers would be keen on trying to win a $100 bonus.”

Real World Experience?

American Theft Prevention did find some retailers who have used this approach, but practical implementation seems very limited.

  1. Over the years, there have been stores that offer employees and/or customers a bonus for catching shoplifters.
  2. In the UK, there’s an online service that pays a reward to viewers who catch a shoplifter by monitoring video at home.
  3. And at least one chain of supermarkets in Singapore is trying this approach with customers. Customers who alert the store to a shoplifter receive a voucher to use in the store.

Concerns

In his book The Retailers Guide to Loss Prevention and Security, author Donald Horan looks that issue of offering rewards to employees. Although employee bonuses are somewhat different than rewards to the public to help combat shoplifting, he does raise some important considerations:

Pluses

Motivation – encourages people to “go beyond the call of duty.”

Positive Example – this will help promote positive action.

Concerns

Disincentive to do what’s expected - For an employee, Loss Prevention is part of the job. To reward a single aspect might be looked at as relieving the employee of LP duties. Is it the public’s duty to report shoplifters?

Bounty Hunting – are you distracting employees from doing their job?  Are you encouraging a group of “customers” who are simply looking for shoplifters.

Unsafe Behavior – are you encouraging street chases and assault to catch a shoplifter, potentially creating an even more unsafe situation, and greater liability.

What’s Rewardable -  What if  someone is simply responding to an Electronic Article Surveillance (EAS) alarm?

What Do You Think?

Do you have experience deterring shoplifting through financial incentives? Do you think this approach will work?

Join our discussion. Lets us know what programs you’ve implemented. What worked and what didn’t.

————————
You can do something about shoplifting! American Theft Prevention Products has tools to help retailers combat shoplifting. Visit www.AmericanTheftPrevention.com or call 866-416-0999 or 847-972-6540.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.